题库> 逻辑 CR> CR-5c16sk

题目选项分析

It is illegal to advertise prescription medications in Hedland except directly to physicians, either by mail or in medical journals. A proposed law would allow general advertising of prescription medications. Opponents object that the general population lacks the specialized knowledge to evaluate such advertisements and might ask their physicians for inappropriate medications. But since physicians have the final say as to whether to prescribe a medication for a patient, inappropriate prescriptions would not become more common.

Which of the following would it be most useful to establish in order to evaluate the argument?

【选项】Whether advertisements for prescription medications are currently an important source of information about newly available medications for physicians

选项是否正确?

答对用户笔记

sqmsqmaa
2人
sqmsqmaa 2018-12-06 18:35:13
advertisements for prescription medications are currently an important source of information about newly available medications for physicians
广告是医生获取处方药信息的重要渠道。要影响的结论是因为医生拥有处方药控制权(premise),所以不会滥用。
广告是不是医生获取的渠道并不影响滥用问题。不管是否重要与否,医生还是拥有判定能力。如果用这个选项过度推理,认为这是医生获取信息的主要来源,所以广告会影响医生的知识的话就是反前提了,因为前提说了general population lacks the specialized knowledge ,也就是说医生是拥有这个知识的。
AQI7777
1人
AQI7777 2017-12-13 21:02:29
是否这些广告是医生们当下获取有关最新药物信息的重要来源。
这个题也是听东哥讲的,不管是不是,因为文中暗示了说,普通没有专业的知识,那医生是有专业知识的。所以这个不能作为评价选项。即便是重要来源,正确与否,医生还是会评判的。

题目基本信息

  • 所属科目:逻辑CR
  • 题目来源1:PREP07 Test 2-35
  • 题目来源2:GWD-7
难度: 难
Get Microsoft Silverlight